Editorial Review · journal-facing triage support
RigorMD Editorial Evaluation

Editorial Review

Focus peer review where it adds the most value. RigorMD Editorial Evaluation gives verified journal editorial offices structured editorial decision support before scarce reviewer and statistical-review capacity is spent.

Structured editorial decision support. Not an editorial decision. Not a replacement for peer review. This public page does not collect manuscripts.
Journal workspace laterNo manuscript upload hereConfidential pilot first

§01 What the pilot report is for

The report is designed to help editors decide where human attention adds the most value: whether a manuscript needs early editorial assessment, statistical or methods review, targeted author clarification, or ordinary external review with clearly defined concerns.

Editorial routing estimate
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.
Topic and audience fit
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.
Design, data, and conclusions fit
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.
Statistical or methods follow-up need
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.
Journal-specific publishing criteria
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.
Highest-yield author queries
Grounded in the supplied PDF and journal context; when the needed material is absent, the report says not assessable rather than guessing.

§02 Phase 0 boundaries

Previously decided, de-identified, or otherwise journal-authorized manuscriptsRequired before any pilot report is produced or delivered to an editorial office.
Confidentiality terms before any manuscript material is processedRequired before any pilot report is produced or delivered to an editorial office.
No model training on uploaded manuscriptsRequired before any pilot report is produced or delivered to an editorial office.
Internal editorial-office use onlyRequired before any pilot report is produced or delivered to an editorial office.
Limits stay visible. Editorial Review does not make the journal decision, determine novelty, replace peer review, replace an independent statistical editor, or use pilot manuscripts for model training. Manuscripts and manuscript-derived report content follow the contracted retention window.